Do you think who the best student is?

[复制链接]
查看11 | 回复5 | 2011-6-3 20:49:15 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式
Do you think who the best student is?还是Do you think who is the best student?
如果是do you think 做插入语呢?
像是What do you think is the best student?还是What do you think the best student is?
(英语书上印的是What do you think is the best student?,老师的解释是what做主语,do you think 是插入语,后面是主系表结构,但是不太清楚如果变成Do you think……的话应该用什么语序)
诶呀,不好意思,是Who do you think is the best student?还是Who do you think the best student is?
如果是Do you think who is the best student?的话,可视为宾语从句,who作主语,而Do you think who the best student is?的话,宾语从句中,the best student 作主语,who作表语,这样解释两种说法就都正确了,我的疑点在这里。

回复

使用道具 举报

千问 | 2011-6-3 20:49:15 | 显示全部楼层
用what疑问代词,用来代替人the best student很不合适。应该用who。哪本书用what接student?至于who do you think the best student is?和who do you think is the best student是否可以见以下分析,二者疑问代词的成分不一样。先去掉插入语看看.who the best student is .这不是一句话,因为词序不对。众所周知插入语是可以去掉的,不可能说插入语去掉了,句子就错了。所以,who do you think the best student is.中do you think 不是插入语。这句话本身就是病句。而Do you think who ...
回复

使用道具 举报

千问 | 2011-6-3 20:49:15 | 显示全部楼层
Do you think who the best student is?和Who do you think is the best student?都是正确的。第一句:是从句,think后省略了连接词that。do you think是主句,后面是从句,从句都要用陈述句语序。第二句:是简单句,do you think只是插入语,可以删掉不看,所以整...
回复

使用道具 举报

千问 | 2011-6-3 20:49:15 | 显示全部楼层
Do you think who is the best student?是正确的.这是复合句,who is the best student是宾语从句,在此从句中,who才是主语,is是谓语。如果do you think作插入语的话,就是What do you think is the best student? 不过一般是用Who,因为对象是人嘛。...
回复

使用道具 举报

千问 | 2011-6-3 20:49:15 | 显示全部楼层
Do you think who the best student is?这里do you think无法做插入语,think 后街宾语从句,用陈述语气。...
回复

使用道具 举报

千问 | 2011-6-3 20:49:15 | 显示全部楼层
应该是do you think who is the best student?do you think 在这两种情况下一样的,顺序改变不影响啥的...
回复

使用道具 举报

您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 立即注册

本版积分规则

主题

0

回帖

4882万

积分

论坛元老

Rank: 8Rank: 8

积分
48824836
热门排行